Staging Orthodontic Tooth Movement with Clear Aligners: Macro- and Micro-Staging Concepts

Staging of Orthodontic Tooth Movement in Clear Aligner Therapy

This narrative review by Martínez-Lozano, Castellanos-Andrés, and López-Jiménez (Appl. Sci. 2024;14:6690) addresses an underexplored yet clinically vital topic: the staging of orthodontic tooth movement in clear aligner therapy. The authors introduce a structured framework—macro-staging and micro-staging—that aims to systematize digital aligner planning and enhance predictability in tooth movement.

From a methodological perspective, this review draws on major orthodontic databases and relevant book chapters, although as a narrative review, it remains limited by its descriptive and non-systematic approach. No statistical synthesis or quality grading of included studies is presented, and thus its conclusions are conceptual rather than evidence-based. However, it provides a useful theoretical scaffold for clinicians navigating the biomechanical intricacies of aligner therapy.

Clinically, the authors remind us that clear aligners operate as closed systems: any unaccounted force can generate unwanted intrusion or “watermelon seed” effects. This reinforces the centrality of controlled space creation through expansion, proclination, IPR, or distalization. They further stress that aligner biomechanics are driven by push surfaces and differential anchorage—principles too often neglected in commercial treatment setups.

Macro-Staging

Macro-staging, in their framework, defines the general biomechanics of the case—how teeth move as groups across the arch. It distinguishes between:

• Simultaneous and structured movement patterns
• Synergistic and antagonistic mechanics

Examples of synergistic combinations (e.g., posterior expansion with anterior retrusion) highlight how certain movements can reinforce one another, while antagonistic pairings (like posterior expansion with anterior protrusion) risk tracking loss. Importantly, the paper clarifies the necessity of anchorage management—whether intra-arch, inter-arch via elastics, or skeletal—and details sequential staging for distalization, vertical control, and space closure.

Micro-Staging

Micro-staging, on the other hand, dives into individual tooth biomechanics: how movements should be phased, prioritized, and spatially coordinated. The authors emphasize:

• The sequencing of space-creating before space-consuming movements
• The careful use of hinge rotations (mesial-out or distal-out) to expand push surfaces and minimize interproximal friction

This discussion is particularly valuable for understanding why round teeth, such as canines and premolars, often fail to derotate predictably under pure rotational programming.

A particularly insightful section addresses vertical discrepancies and the challenge of flattening the curve of Spee—a persistent weak point of aligner therapy. The proposed three-phase sequence (alignment, canine intrusion, incisor intrusion) represents a rational and clinically translatable strategy. Likewise, the treatment of extraction cases with “segmental” or “caterpillar” motion is a pragmatic refinement that mitigates the bowing effect of aligner plastic.

The authors openly acknowledge the review’s limitations—chiefly, the lack of empirical evidence to support or refute specific staging protocols. Yet the conceptual clarity and integration of practical examples (with figures illustrating real cases) make it a substantial pedagogical contribution. The key message is that treatment predictability in clear aligner therapy is not merely a function of plastic properties or attachment design, but of how intelligently movements are staged in space and time.

In summary, this review provides clinicians with a biomechanical map for planning aligner treatments that go beyond software defaults. The distinction between macro- and micro-staging adds a valuable layer of analytical thinking to virtual setups and may serve as a framework for future quantitative studies. It is a timely call for orthodontists to reclaim control of digital planning with an understanding grounded in biomechanics rather than marketing algorithms.

Reference: Martínez-Lozano D, Castellanos-Andrés D, López-Jiménez AJ. Staging of Orthodontic Tooth Movement in Clear Aligner Treatment: Macro-Staging and Micro-Staging—A Narrative Review. Appl. Sci. 2024;14(15):6690. https://doi.org/10.3390/app14156690

➡️ View Dr. Baxmann‘s Books